The Common Contract Disputes in a Real Estate Transaction

Purchasing or selling real estate can be fun yet legally intricate process. One of the notable challenges that can arise are contract disputes. Understanding these common contract disputes in a real estate transaction and how to prevent them is essential for ensuring a smooth transaction. This article delves into the common contract disputes in a real estate transaction and offers practical strategies to mitigate them effectively.

Steve Daria and Joleigh, both seasoned real estate investors, frequently encounter contract disputes during their transactions. One common issue they face is the ambiguity in contract terms, which can lead to disagreements over property conditions and timelines. To navigate these legal challenges effectively, they recommend thorough due diligence and clear communication during negotiation.

Understanding Contract Disputes in Real Estate

Before exploring specific common contract disputes in a real estate transaction, it’s crucial to grasp what constitutes a contract dispute in real estate. 

A contract dispute arises when one party believes that the other has failed to do their obligations as outlined in the contract.  

1. Misunderstanding Contract Terms

Many common contract disputes in a real estate transaction stem from misunderstandings or misinterpretations of the contract terms. 

Real estate contracts often use complex legal language that may be open to different interpretations. 

This ambiguity can lead to disagreements regarding responsibilities, deadlines, property conditions, and other critical aspects of the transaction.

Examples of Misunderstandings

• Misinterpretation of Property Boundaries: Disputes may arise if the exact boundaries of the property are not clearly defined in the contract.
• Ambiguity over Fixtures and Fittings: Parties may disagree on whether certain fixtures or fittings are included in the sale.
• Confusion about Timelines: Unclear timelines for completing home inspections, securing financing, or closing the transaction can lead to disputes.

How to Avoid Misunderstandings

To prevent misunderstandings:

• Consult a Real Estate Attorney: Have a qualified attorney review the contract to ensure clarity and understanding of all terms.
• Clarify Ambiguous Terms: Seek clarification on any unclear terms or provisions before signing the contract.

2. Breach of Contract

A breach of contract occurs when one person fails to fulfill their responsibility under the terms of the agreement. 

This can occur in various ways, such as failing to make payments, missing deadlines, or not delivering the property as agreed upon.

Common Breaches in Real Estate

• Seller Failing to Complete Agreed Repairs: If a seller promises to make repairs before closing but fails to do so, it constitutes a breach.
• Buyer Failing to Secure Financing: If a buyer cannot secure financing within the agreed timeframe, it breaches the contract.
• Non-Attendance at Closing: If either party fails to appear at the closing without a valid reason, it can lead to disputes.

Resolving Breach of Contract Issues

• Send a Formal Notice: Notify the breaching party formally about the breach and request compliance.
• Consider Mediation: Use a mediator to facilitate discussions and resolve the dispute amicably.
• Legal Action: As a last resort, litigation may be necessary to enforce contract terms and seek damages.

---

---

3. Inspection and Disclosure Disputes

Inspections and disclosures are critical to uncovering the true condition of the property and any potential issues. 

Disputes can arise if there are discrepancies between disclosed information and actual property conditions discovered during inspections.

Examples of Disputes

• Failure to Disclose Pest Infestations: If the seller did not disclose a known pest problem that is discovered during an evaluation, it can lead to disputes.
• Disagreement over Repair Costs: Parties may dispute who is responsible for covering the cost of necessary repairs revealed during inspections.
• Misrepresentation of Property Condition: If the seller misrepresents the property’s condition, it can result in legal disputes.

Tips to Avoid Inspection Disputes

• Thorough Inspections: Conduct comprehensive inspections of the property before finalizing the contract.
• Complete Disclosures: Sellers should disclose all known issues upfront to avoid surprises during inspections.

4. Financing Issues

Financing disputes commonly arise when a buyer encounters difficulties securing a loan as agreed upon in the contract terms.

Common Financing Disputes

• Delayed Loan Approval: If the buyer’s loan approval takes longer than expected, it can delay the transaction and lead to disputes.
• Changes in Financing Terms: Unexpected changes in interest rates or loan conditions can affect the buyer’s ability to proceed with the purchase.
• Disputes over Earnest Money: If the buyer cannot secure financing and the contract specifies conditions for earnest money return, disputes may arise over its refund.

Solutions for Financing Disputes

• Pre-Approval: Buyers should obtain pre-approval for a mortgage before making an offer to mitigate financing uncertainties.
• Include Contingencies: Contracts should include contingencies related to financing to protect both parties if issues arise.

5. Title Disputes

Title disputes can derail a real estate transaction if there are unresolved issues regarding property ownership or liens on the property.

Common Title Disputes

• Unpaid Property Taxes: Disputes may arise if there are outstanding property taxes that need to be settled before the transaction can proceed.
• Claims by Previous Owners: Claims by previous owners or undisclosed heirs can complicate the title transfer process.
• Boundary Disputes: Disagreements over property boundaries can delay or halt the transaction.

How to Resolve Title Disputes

• Conduct a Thorough Title Search: Before closing, conduct a comprehensive title search to recognize any existing liens or claims on the property.
• Title Insurance: Purchase title insurance to secure against unexpected title issues that may arise after the transaction.

6. Appraisal Discrepancies

Appraisal disputes occur when there is a significant difference between the appraised value of the property and the agreed-upon purchase price.

Common Appraisal Disputes

• Low Appraisal Value: If the property appraises for less than the agreed purchase price, it can lead to renegotiation or contract termination.
• Disagreements on Property Value Factors: Parties may dispute the appraiser’s methodology or the impact of property improvements on its value.

Strategies to Address Appraisal Issues

• Seek a Second Opinion: Consider obtaining a second appraisal to verify the accuracy of the initial appraisal.
• Negotiation: Parties can negotiate a new purchase price based on the appraisal results to resolve disputes.

7. Contingency Disputes

Contingencies are conditions that must be complied with for the transaction to proceed as outlined in the contract.

Common Contingency Disputes

• Sale of Buyer’s Current Home: If a buyer’s contingency to sell their current home is not met within the agreed timeframe, it can delay the transaction.
• Inspection Contingencies: Issues discovered during inspections that are not adequately addressed can lead to disputes.
• Financing Contingencies: If the buyer fails to get financing within the specified period, it can jeopardize the transaction.

Navigating Contingency Disputes

• Clear Contractual Language: Clearly outline all contingencies in the contract to avoid misunderstandings.
• Regular Communication: Maintain ongoing communication between parties to address any contingency-related issues promptly.

8. Closing Date Conflicts

Closing date conflicts can arise if either party is not ready to close on the agreed-upon date.

Common Closing Date Disputes

• Delays in Financing: If there are delays in securing financing, it may postpone the closing date.
• Unexpected Discoveries: Issues discovered during the final walkthrough can lead to disagreements over closing conditions.
• Disagreements on Closing Costs: Disputes may arise regarding who is responsible for paying certain closing costs.

How to Handle Closing Date Conflicts

• Flexibility: Remain flexible and willing to negotiate a new closing date if unforeseen circumstances arise.
• Open Communication: Keep lines of communication open to discuss and resolve any issues affecting the closing date.

9. Earnest Money Disputes

Refers to a deposit done by the buyer to show their commitment to the transaction.

Common Earnest Money Disputes

• Buyer Backing Out: If the buyer withdraws from the contract for reasons not covered by contract contingencies, disputes over earnest money may arise.
• Seller Cancellation: If the seller cancels the contract without valid reasons, the buyer may seek the return of earnest money.
• Failure to Meet Contingencies: If a party fails to meet contract contingencies, disputes may arise over the earnest money deposit.

Resolving Earnest Money Disputes

• Clear Contractual Terms: Specify conditions for earnest money in the contract to avoid ambiguity.
• Mediation: Utilize mediation to resolve disputes and reach a mutually agreeable solution regarding earnest money.

Remedies for Contract Disputes

Depending on the nature of the dispute, various remedies may be pursued to resolve contract disputes.

Common Remedies

• Negotiation: Direct discussions between parties to find a resolution.
• Mediation: Involvement of a neutral third party to process agreement.
• Litigation: Taking the dispute to court for legal judgment and enforcement of contract terms.

Preventing Common Contract Disputes in a Real Estate Transaction

The best approach to handling common contract disputes in a real estate transaction is to prevent them from occurring in the first place through proactive measures.

• Clear and Detailed Contracts: Ensure contracts are comprehensive, clearly outlining all terms and conditions.
• Regular Communication: Maintain ongoing communication between all parties involved in the transaction.
• Legal Guidance: Seek advice from a real estate attorney when drafting or reviewing contracts to ensure legal compliance and clarity.

Conclusion

Navigating real estate transactions involves understanding and addressing common contract disputes effectively. Whether you are buying or selling property, being aware of possible issues and implementing strategies to prevent and resolve disputes can streamline the process and minimize stress. 

**NOTICE:  Please note that the content presented in this post is intended solely for informational and educational purposes. It should not be construed as legal or financial advice or relied upon as a replacement for consultation with a qualified attorney or CPA. For specific guidance on legal or financial matters, readers are encouraged to seek professional assistance from an attorney, CPA, or other appropriate professional regarding the subject matter.